Egg Custard Pie
on Jul 15, 2020, Updated Apr 28, 2021
This post may contain affiliate links. Please read our disclosure policy.
Egg custard pie is a light-tasting, sweet treat. This is an ideal summer dessert because it isn’t too heavy while still adding a nice finish to any meal. Or as a little afternoon delight. At just 244 calories per slice, this easy dessert recipe isn’t going to put you over the top!
Make this easy egg custard pie in about an hour.
Table of Contents
Homemade pie recipes have always been cIose to my heart. I first fell in love with custard pies when my sister-in-law Carol (aka “The Pie Queen”) started making her raspberry custard pie.
But it doesn’t stop there! I love all sorts of pies. A couple of my many favorite pie recipes include this Chocolate Bourbon Pecan Pie and Shoo Fly Pie, which I practically consider to be a blood relative of mine.
Today’s recipe is a base for all of those wonderful berries desserts that Carol makes. The beauty of this egg pie is that it stands firmly (no pun intended), by itself. It just may be the best thing I’ve tasted since sliced bread!
🥧 What is it?
Remember hearing that simple is best? This dessert proves that point. This is a simple, old-fashioned, no-frills dessert recipe.
You can serve it by itself or top it with
- Vanilla ice cream
- Homemade whipped cream
- Sliced peaches
- Fresh berries
- Nutmeg
It’s perfect for company or for a major holiday meal, like Thanksgiving dinner. The bottom line: This easy homemade pie tastes great any day of the year.
🥘 What’s in it?
The shortlist of ingredients is part of what makes this recipe so appealing.
- Eggs
- Sugar
- Vanilla
- Nutmeg
- Salt
- Egg white
- Pie crust
🥣 How to make it
Start by gathering your ingredients. To save some time, you can always use a store-bought crust. If you want to learn how to make a pie crust, we are more than happy to show you the way!
Pro Baking Tip – Always use eggs at room temperature when baking. This will help your recipe to bake evenly. Here is a great trick for how to bring eggs to room temperature quickly.
- Combine eggs, sugar, salt, and, vanilla into a large mixing bowl.
- Add the scalded milk to the rest of the ingredients, after it has cooled.
- Be sure the milk is cooled before adding it, so you don’t end up with scrambled eggs!
- Scalding the milk is optional, see FAQ below.
- Whisk it all together.
- Use a pastry brush and coat the inside of the pie crust with the egg white.
- Pour the filling into the crust.
- Use a fine-mesh strainer to top the pie filling with the ground nutmeg.
If you’re new at making homemade pies, this is a great recipe to get you started!
Once you have everything put together, you’ll bake it for 40-50 minutes at 400°F, until it is set.
💭 Common questions
How do you know when an egg custard pie is done?
This is done baking when the edges are firm but the center gently jiggles when you gently shake the pan. Don’t over-bake!
Do egg custard pies need to be refrigerated?
Any recipe that contains eggs or dairy should be refrigerated as soon as it is cooled to room temperature.
- Seal it with kitchen wrap
- Refrigerate it for up to two days
Can I use evaporated milk?
For a smooth and creamy texture, you can substitute regular milk for any of the following.
- Evaporated milk
- Sweetened condensed milk
- Half and half
- Cream
Pro Cooking Tip: It is not necessary to scald any of these before adding it to the eggs. Warming them, to at least room temperature or above, will enhance the baking process!
Why is scalded milk used in some recipes?
Back in the days before pasteurization, milk was scalded to help eliminate any nasty bacteria that may have been in the milk. Even though today’s milk is pasteurized, scalding milk before baking with it can add some nice touches to your recipe.
- Milk is a great way to infuse flavor and can help incorporate things like vanilla beans, cinnamon, mint leaves, and many other common baking ingredients.
- Scaling milk first will help butter melt and yeast to rise in some recipes like homemade bread.
Do I have to par-bake the crust before filling?
You don’t have to par-bake the crust for this egg custard pie. Brushing the pie shell before baking will help to keep it from getting soggy.
If you like this dessert recipe, you’ll love our Old-Fashioned Butter Tarts as well!
I grew eating this type of dessert, and I’m afraid my waistline shows it. Still, I wouldn’t change a thing. My Mennonite Mom could whip up this egg custard pie like it was nobody’s business all the while juggling an armful of other tasks.
A good homemade pie always takes me back to those magical days of growing up on the farm and knowing first-hand the meaning of real food.
I hope you’ll give this easy dessert recipe a try, and be sure and let us know how you like it! Leaving a comment below is one way we know that you’re reading our recipes. It’s almost as good as seeing the smile on your face after tasting this pie. Thanks for reading Platter Talk, it means the world to us!
👨🍳 Tried this Recipe? Please leave a ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ rating in the recipe card below and leave a comment. We love hearing from our readers!
⏩ Stay in touch with us on social media by following us on Facebook, Pinterest, Instagram, and YouTube!
📬Get our Recipes delivered to your inbox for FREE!
⏲️ Egg Custard Pie
Equipment
Ingredients
- 3 Eggs, beaten
- 3/4 cups Sugar
- 1/4 tsp Salt
- 1 tsp Vanilla extract
- 1 Egg white, beaten for an egg wash
- 1 Pie shell, pre-made
- 2 1/2 cups Milk, scalded
- 1/2 tsp Nutmeg
Instructions
- Preheat your oven to 400° F. Combine the egg, sugar, salt, and vanilla in a large mixing bowl. Pour the milk in with the other ingredients and whisk to combine. If using scalded milk, be sure it has cooled before adding.
- Use a pastry brush to coat the inside of the pie shell with the egg wash. pour the filling into the prepared shell and sprinkle the nutmeg on top, using a fine-mesh strainer
- Bake for 40 to 50 minutes until the edges of the pie are firm and the center jiggles a bit Allow to cool on a cooling rack and then refrigerate before serving.
Video
Notes
Nutrition
Nutrition information is automatically calculated, so should only be used as an approximation.
More Delicious Pie Recipes
Homemade Pies
Open Face Apple Pie
Desserts
Peach Pie and Pie Crust Recipe
Homemade Pies
The BEST Homemade Pecan Pie (without Corn Syrup)
Desserts
Made this for my sister’s birthday at her request. It was a big hit! We also were raised in a Mennonite home. It’s a great heritage! Take care and keep on cooking!
Hello Susan! Thanks for the awesome feedback! If you have any favorite recipes from the past, please email them to me and maybe we can get them on the site. Thanks again for taking the time to leave a comment.
I made this YUMMY pie for friends whose mom passed away a year ago. They were discussing how they missed her egg custard pie. I took a stab at it and shared with them. They all loved it!! Win – – Win!
I use your recipe for my rice pudding, custard. My husband likes the tall custard on top of the rice and raisins.
Your recipe is perfect.
Thank you!
This recipe is WONDERFUL! Iโve made 6 pies and they all turned out amazing!
HI! I’m Steph’s BFF. My first pie is in the oven as we speak. Hopefully mine will be as good as hers!!
I love this recipe. Splenda works well for sugar since I am diabetic!
Did using Splenda cut the carbs
Hi, this might be a dumb question but oh well here goes……
do you bake the pie crust first or bake it all at once?
Hi Kim. Not a dumb question at all. You can blind-bake the crust for 5-7 minutes, but it should not be necessary. Please note that if you buy a frozen crust from the store, you will want to ensure it is thawed out and at room temperature before adding the custard filling and baking it. Good luck!
Any pie crust is better if you bake it first before adding ingredients. Especially if you like it crispy (and we do ๐)
I must have done something wrong. I admit my husband cut the pie after the pie had only been out of the oven for about ten minutes, but there was a lot of liquid in the bottom of the pan when ha was cut. I didnโt see a cooling time, would the liquid been absorbed if we had waited to cut it? I cooked it the whole 50 minutes and I donโt think it was undercooked. Any suggestions on why this might have happened? I really wanted to love this recipe because we have fresh eggs. Hopefully Iโll get an answer ti what happened.
Hi Deena. I’m bummed out that you had this experience with our recipe. I’m not sure what happened, as quite a few variables are involved. If you haven’t already, please look at the many comments other readers have left. There are many helpful suggestions; please let me know if you figured this out and what you did to make it less liquid.
Hi Deena!
The pie must cool COMPLETELY before cutting. When you remove it from the oven, the center should still be liquid and jiggle. As it cools, it becomes firm. So it’s important to let it cool all the way. Then put in the refrigerator. Sorry you didn’t get to enjoy it. Give it another shot and hide it from hubby!
I donโt care for pie crust. Do you think you could substitute a graham cracker crust in this recipe?
Hi Kelly, yes, you could do that, and it would be delicious!
You don’t have to have a crust. Just put the filling in an ovenproof casserole dish & bake as recipe says. It’s just called custard pudding.
Excellent and so classic! This got rave reviews at thanksgiving.
Thanks for the feedback Katie; sounds like you had a wonderful meal if it ended with this!
Great recipe easy to make taste delicious. So easy to make.
Albert, Thanks for the great feedback, and so happy you enjoyed this popular dessert! Please share the recipe link with your friends and family on social media!
Going to make this for my husband who can’t have starches or sugar with my pecan crust:
โข food processor ground pecans
โข pan melt a stick of butter, tablespoon molasses, 1/2 cup of splenda baking blend.
โข mix in pecans to the melted mix and then press in the pie dish and prepare like graham cracker crust. Family loves it.